OxTalks is Changing
On 28th November OxTalks will move to the new Halo platform and will become 'Oxford Events' (full details are available on the Staff Gateway).
There will be an OxTalks freeze beginning on Friday 14th November. This means you will need to publish any of your known events to OxTalks by then as there will be no facility to publish or edit events in that fortnight. During the freeze, all events will be migrated to the new Oxford Events site. It will still be possible to view events on OxTalks during this time.
If you have any questions, please contact halo@digital.ox.ac.uk
Responsive to What? Explaining the Information Quality of Public Comments on Bureaucratic Policymaking Using a Text-as-Data Approach
When are public comments characterized by high information quality more likely to occur in bureaucratic policymaking? We answer this question using a text-as-data approach applied to an original dataset covering more than 20,000 comments across 1,037 policy acts issued by the European Commission. We construct four measures capturing our multi-dimensional concept of information quality of comments. Our argument emphasizes the interplay between the demand and supply of information provision and highlights the critical role of institutional factors in explaining comments’ information quality. We find that high-quality comments are more likely to emerge during the policy formulation stage and, counterintuitively, in relation to EC policy documents that are informationally dense and syntactically complex. We find no systematic co-variation between a policy area’s established or scientific status and comment quality. Our findings provide novel insights into how the design of public commenting procedures and crafting policy acts shape comments’ information quality.
Date:
17 October 2025, 13:00
Venue:
Manor Road Building, Manor Road OX1 3UQ
Venue Details:
Room TBD
Speaker:
Adriana Bunea (University of Bergen)
Organising department:
Department of Politics and International Relations (DPIR)
Part of:
Politics Research Colloquium
Booking required?:
Not required
Audience:
Members of the University only
Editor:
Alexander Kuo
